Wednesday, 30 April 2025

Ulysses by James Joyce - an intro

Ulysses is a famously difficult novel for the average reader. It is written in 18 sections, each with a title taken from Homer's Odyssey which Joyce used as a schema for plotting the novel. 

I read the  Oxford World's Classic version which has a detailed introduction and about 250 pages of appendices and explanatory notes on the text. The notes proved extremely useful, though the author has this warning:

The very idea of annotating Ulysses overwhelm. Both of the questions, "Where does one begin? and, perhaps more practically, "Where does one stop?" utterly disconcert.

Joyce himself said:

I've put in so many enigmas and puzzles that it will keep the professors busy for centuries arguing over what I meant, and that's the only way of insuring one's immortality.

Connection between The Odyssey and Ulysses 
The Odyssey follows Odysseus’ epic ten-year journey home after the Trojan War. He has many adventures on the way:
  • Cicones: A raid gone awry.
  • Lotus-Eaters: Men who consume the forgetful lotus plant.
  • Cyclops Polyphemus: Odysseus blinds the one-eyed giant, inciting Poseidon's wrath.
  • Aeolus: The wind god gifts a bag of winds; the crew's curiosity leads to misfortune.
  • Laestrygonians: Cannibalistic giants destroy all ships but Odysseus's.
  • Circe: The enchantress turns men into swine; Odysseus, protected by Hermes, resists and stays for a year.
  • Underworld: Odysseus consults the prophet Tiresias and encounters spirits of the dead.
  • Sirens: Their song lures sailors to doom; Odysseus listens while bound to the mast.
  • Scylla and Charybdis: Navigating between a six-headed monster and a deadly whirlpool. 
  • Thrinacia: Crew slaughters sacred cattle of Helios; Zeus punishes them with a storm, leaving Odysseus adrift
Ulysses focusses this 10-year journey down to a single day (June 16, 1904) in Dublin, following Leopold Bloom as he navigates the city. It was on this day James Joyce had his first date with Nora Barnacle, his life-long partner and wife - he was 22 and she was 20. Nora serves as a model for Molly Bloom 

The 16th of June is now celebrated each year in Dublin as "Bloomsday" - see below

The Three Main Characters
Odysseus the warrior is transposed to Leopold Bloom, a middle-aged jewish advertising salesman: Both are wandering figures, facing obstacles on their journey home.
Telemachus, Odysseus' son, is mirrored by Stephen Dedalus a scholar and teacher. Both struggle with identity and father figures.
Penelope, Odysseus’ wife, becomes Molly Bloom. But where Penelope waits faithfully for the return of her husband, Molly has an affair.

A Guide is Essential
I knew I was in for a difficult read so I bought Patrick Hastings excellent guide, which is also available on his website (link below). Hastings is not only a great help in clarifying the complexities of each section and how each links to The Odyssey but also in showing how the many threads of the novel tie together. Above all the guide is humorous and reassuring, encouraging the reader to persevere through the obstacles. I would never have got through Ulysses without it.

What follows is a taster of both the novel and the guide. I have copied the first lines of text of each of the 18 sections from Project Gutenburg, followed by the first part of the guide notes from Hastings' website, so you can see how the novel changes in character and style and how the guide helps. Occassionally I have removed parts of the text, shown by ..............

If you find going through these exerpts too tedious then scroll to the bottom for some links to articles, podcasts and videos. Reading, hearing and watching about Ulysses and Joyce is perhaps more interesting than the novel itself!


This link is a short summary and the best place to start
Why should you read James Joyce's "Ulysses"? - Sam Slote



Ch1. Telemachus 

Stephen Dedalus is searching for a father figure and meaning.

Stately, plump Buck Mulligan came from the stairhead, bearing a bowl of lather on which a mirror and a razor lay crossed. A yellow dressinggown, ungirdled, was sustained gently behind him on the mild morning air. He held the bowl aloft and intoned:

Introibo ad altare Dei*. Halted, he peered down the dark winding stairs and called out coarsely:
Come up, Kinch! Come up, you fearful jesuit!
Solemnly he came forward and mounted the round gunrest. He faced about and blessed gravely thrice the tower, the surrounding land and the awaking mountains. Then, catching sight of Stephen Dedalus, he bent towards him and made rapid crosses in the air, gurgling in his throat and shaking his head. Stephen Dedalus, displeased and sleepy, leaned his arms on the top of the staircase and looked coldly at the shaking gurgling face that blessed him, equine in its length, and at the light untonsured hair, grained and hued like pale oak.

*I will go to the altar of God

Guide
Ulysses opens on the rooftop of the Martello Tower at 8:00 am on the morning of June 16th, 1904. Buck Mulligan, a medical student in his 20s, looks out over Sandycove, a bayside suburb just south of Dublin, and begins to parody the Catholic mass as he prepares to shave his face. He calls back down “the dark winding stairs” for Stephen Dedalus to join him in the mild morning air.

My general advice: seek explanations for the allusions that genuinely pique your curiosity, but please don’t feel compelled to look up everything that you don’t know. Lots of stuff is going to fly over your head. Let it.


(My note: Stephen Dedalus' story, prior to Ulysses, is told in Joyce's "Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man".)

Ch2. Nestor

Stephen is teaching in a school. He talks with Mr. Deasy, mirroring Telemachus’s search for advice.

—You, Cochrane, what city sent for him?
—Tarentum, sir.
—Very good. Well?
—There was a battle, sir.
—Very good. Where?
The boy’s blank face asked the blank window.
Fabled by the daughters of memory. And yet it was in some way if not as memory fabled it. A phrase, then, of impatience, thud of Blake’s wings of excess. I hear the ruin of all space, shattered glass and toppling masonry, and time one livid final flame. What’s left us then?
—I forget the place, sir. 279 B. C.
—Asculum, Stephen said, glancing at the name and date in the gorescarred book.
—Yes, sir. And he said: Another victory like that and we are done for.

That phrase the world had remembered*. A dull ease of the mind. From a hill above a corpsestrewn plain a general speaking to his officers, leaned upon his spear. Any general to any officers. They lend ear.

—You, Armstrong, Stephen said. What was the end of Pyrrhus?
—End of Pyrrhus, sir?
—I know, sir. Ask me, sir, Comyn said.
—Wait. You, Armstrong. Do you know anything about Pyrrhus?


* Pyrric victory

Guide quote
The “Nestor” episode depicts Stephen at work as a teacher at a private boys’ school in Dalkey, which is about a 20 minute walk south from the Martello Tower. We know Stephen departed the tower no sooner than 8:45 am (the bells chimed three quarters past the hour at the end of “Telemachus”), so he presumably arrives a few minutes past 9:00 am. He is late to work.

Ch3 Proteus

Stephen wanders Sandymount Strand, contemplating perception and reality (shifting like Proteus, a sea god who could assume many forms).

(My note: this is the point where many give up. Everything is going on inside Stephen's head - stream of conscious
ness writing. I just ploughed on, taking Hastings advice to let words, sentences and meaning fly over my head, and then began to actually find some meaning and even enjoyment)

Ineluctable modality of the visible: at least that if no more, thought through my eyes. Signatures of all things I am here to read, seaspawn and seawrack, the nearing tide, that rusty boot. Snotgreen, bluesilver, rust: coloured signs. Limits of the diaphane. But he adds: in bodies. Then he was aware of them bodies before of them coloured. How? By knocking his sconce against them, sure. Go easy. Bald he was and a millionaire, maestro di color che sanno. Limit of the diaphane in. Why in? Diaphane, adiaphane. If you can put your five fingers through it it is a gate, if not a door. Shut your eyes and see.

Guide
The “Proteus” episode depicts the erudite musings of Stephen Dedalus as he walks along Sandymount Strand just before 11:00 am. Dense and difficult to follow, “Proteus” is where most first time readers of Ulysses throw in the towel. Don’t. Despite the fact that even the most serious Joycean could spend an entire career reading deeply in this episode, you needn’t get bogged down if you don’t want to. In this guide, I’ll give you what you need to continue your momentum toward meeting Mr. Bloom in the next episode.

Ch4 Calypso

Leopold Bloom is introduced at home with Molly; domestic details replace the mythic.

Mr Leopold Bloom ate with relish the inner organs of beasts and fowls. He liked thick giblet soup, nutty gizzards, a stuffed roast heart, liverslices fried with crustcrumbs, fried hencods’ roes. Most of all he liked grilled mutton kidneys which gave to his palate a fine tang of faintly scented urine.
Kidneys were in his mind as he moved about the kitchen softly, righting her breakfast things on the humpy tray. Gelid light and air were in the kitchen but out of doors gentle summer morning everywhere. Made him feel a bit peckish.
The coals were reddening.
Another slice of bread and butter: three, four: right. She didn’t like her plate full. Right. He turned from the tray, lifted the kettle off the hob and set it sideways on the fire. It sat there, dull and squat, its spout stuck out. Cup of tea soon. Good. Mouth dry. The cat walked stiffly round a leg of the table with tail on high.
—Mkgnao!
—O, there you are, Mr Bloom said, turning from the fire.
The cat mewed in answer and stalked again stiffly round a leg of the table, mewing. Just how she stalks over my writingtable. Prr. Scratch my head. Prr.
Mr Bloom watched curiously, kindly the lithe black form. Clean to see: the gloss of her sleek hide, the white button under the butt of her tail, the green flashing eyes. He bent down to her, his hands on his knees.


Guide
Just as Book Five of The Odyssey shifts focus from Telemachus to Odysseus, the “Calypso” episode restarts the story of Ulysses in Mr. Bloom’s home (7 Eccles Street) at 8:00 am on the morning of June 16th 1904. Leaving behind Stephen’s intensity and density of thought, you’ll likely find Mr. Bloom’s arrival on the page a relief. As we begin the novel’s second triad of episodes in the initial style, the text continues to provide intimate access to the focalized character’s thoughts by the techniques of inner monologue and free indirect discourse, but the third person narrator now adopts Mr. Bloom’s comic sensibility and groundedness in the physical world. We swap the erudition of Stephen’s interiority for Mr. Bloom’s reliance on external stimuli for his frames of reference and mental activity.


Ch5 Lotus Eaters

Bloom drifts through Dublin, distracted, passive, like the dreaminess of the Lotus-Eaters.

By lorries along Sir John Rogerson’s quay Mr Bloom walked soberly, past Windmill lane, Leask’s the linseed crusher, the postal telegraph office. Could have given that address too. And past the sailors’ home. He turned from the morning noises of the quayside and walked through Lime street. By Brady’s cottages a boy for the skins lolled, his bucket of offal linked, smoking a chewed fagbutt. A smaller girl with scars of eczema on her forehead eyed him, listlessly holding her battered caskhoop. Tell him if he smokes he won’t grow. O let him! His life isn’t such a bed of roses. Waiting outside pubs to bring da home. Come home to ma, da. Slack hour: won’t be many there. He crossed Townsend street, passed the frowning face of Bethel. El, yes: house of: Aleph, Beth. And past Nichols’ the undertaker. At eleven it is. Time enough. Daresay Corny Kelleher bagged the job for O’Neill’s. Singing with his eyes shut. Corny. Met her once in the park. In the dark. What a lark. Police tout. Her name and address she then told with my tooraloom tooraloom tay. O, surely he bagged it. Bury him cheap in a whatyoumaycall. With my tooraloom, tooraloom, tooraloom, tooraloom.

Guide
The opening of “Lotus-Eaters” finds Bloom on the south bank of the Liffey, and he will cover about a mile over the course of this episode. Note that Mr. Bloom’s southerly walk echoes Stephen’s concurrent commute from the Tower to the school, and, for future reference, note also that he probably takes the same route (though in the opposite direction) as he will take home from the Cabman’s shelter about 15 hours hence.

Ch6 Hades

Bloom attends Paddy Dignam’s funeral — confronting mortality (a "descent" into the underworld).

Martin Cunningham, first, poked his silkhatted head into the creaking carriage and, entering deftly, seated himself. Mr Power stepped in after him, curving his height with care.
—Come on, Simon.
—After you, Mr Bloom said.
Mr Dedalus covered himself quickly and got in, saying:
—Yes, yes.
—Are we all here now? Martin Cunningham asked. Come along, Bloom.
Mr Bloom entered and sat in the vacant place. He pulled the door to after him and slammed it twice till it shut tight. He passed an arm through the armstrap and looked seriously from the open carriagewindow at the lowered blinds of the avenue. One dragged aside: an old woman peeping. Nose whiteflattened against the pane. Thanking her stars she was passed over. Extraordinary the interest they take in a corpse. Glad to see us go we give them such trouble coming. Job seems to suit them. Huggermugger in corners. Slop about in slipperslappers for fear he’d wake. Then getting it ready. Laying it out. Molly and Mrs Fleming making the bed. Pull it more to your side. Our windingsheet. Never know who will touch you dead. Wash and shampoo. I believe they clip the nails and the hair. Keep a bit in an envelope. Grows all the same after. Unclean job.
All waited. Nothing was said. Stowing in the wreaths probably. I am sitting on something hard. Ah, that soap: in my hip pocket. Better shift it out of that. Wait for an opportunity.
All waited. Then wheels were heard from in front, turning: then nearer: then horses’ hoofs. A jolt. Their carriage began to move, creaking and swaying. Other hoofs and creaking wheels started behind. The blinds of the avenue passed and number nine with its craped knocker, door ajar. At walking pace.
They waited still, their knees jogging, till they had turned and were passing along the tramtracks. Tritonville road. Quicker. The wheels rattled rolling over the cobbled causeway and the crazy glasses shook rattling in the doorframes.
—What way is he taking us? Mr Power asked through both windows.
—Irishtown, Martin Cunningham said. Ringsend. Brunswick street.
Mr Dedalus nodded, looking out.

Guide
As Mr. Bloom has planned all morning, he joins Paddy Dignam’s funeral cortege at 11 am. Together with Martin Cunningham, Jack Power, and Simon Dedalus (Stephen’s father), Mr. Bloom will traverse Dublin by horse-drawn carriage, beginning at the Dignam home in the southeast corner of central Dublin (just east of the Aviva Stadium noted on the Google Earth path to the right), going through the heart of the City Center, and ending at Glasnevin Cemetery in the north).


In Homer’s Odyssey, “Hades” is the land of the dead, to which Odysseus travels in order to learn from the great prophet Tiresias how he might return to his home in Ithaca. Likewise, Mr. Bloom in this episode visits the memories of loved one who have passed away and wrestles with thoughts of his own home, where his wife Molly and her lover Blazes Boylan will meet later this afternoon.

Ch7 Aeolus

At a newspaper office; the "winds" are metaphors for gossip, chatter, and headlines.

IN THE HEART OF THE HIBERNIAN METROPOLIS
Before Nelson’s pillar trams slowed, shunted, changed trolley, started for Blackrock, Kingstown and Dalkey, Clonskea, Rathgar and Terenure, Palmerston Park and upper Rathmines, Sandymount Green, Rathmines, Ringsend and Sandymount Tower, Harold’s Cross. The hoarse Dublin United Tramway Company’s timekeeper bawled them off:
—Rathgar and Terenure!
—Come on, Sandymount Green!
Right and left parallel clanging ringing a doubledecker and a singledeck moved from their railheads, swerved to the down line, glided parallel.
—Start, Palmerston Park!

THE WEARER OF THE CROWN
Under the porch of the general post office shoeblacks called and polished. Parked in North Prince’s street His Majesty’s vermilion mailcars, bearing on their sides the royal initials, E. R., received loudly flung sacks of letters, postcards, lettercards, parcels, insured and paid, for local, provincial, British and overseas delivery.

GENTLEMEN OF THE PRESS
Grossbooted draymen rolled barrels dullthudding out of Prince’s stores and bumped them up on the brewery float. On the brewery float bumped dullthudding barrels rolled by grossbooted draymen out of Prince’s stores.
—There it is, Red Murray said. Alexander Keyes.
—Just cut it out, will you? Mr Bloom said, and I’ll take it round to the Telegraph office.
The door of Ruttledge’s office creaked again. Davy Stephens, minute in a large capecoat, a small felt hat crowning his ringlets, passed out with a roll of papers under his cape, a king’s courier.
Red Murray’s long shears sliced out the advertisement from the newspaper in four clean strokes. Scissors and paste.
—I’ll go through the printingworks, Mr Bloom said, taking the cut square.
—Of course, if he wants a par, Red Murray said earnestly, a pen behind his ear, we can do him one.
—Right, Mr Bloom said with a nod. I’ll rub that in.

Guide

The “Aeolus” episode, with its newspaper headlines, represents the first of many chapters where Joyce pushes the boundaries of the novel as a form. Can a novel contain newspaper headlines? Is a novel still a novel if ⅕ th of it is written as a play? What if it also contains a catechism? How do these devices alter the reading experience?

Joyce saw all forms of language - from Dublin slang to Deuteronomy, from pop music lyrics to Virgil’s Eclogues, from advertising slogans to Shakespeare - as fodder for the great project of Ulysses. In the case of this episode’s headlines (which Joyce added to the text at proof stage) we immediately notice their effect of simultaneously interrupting and framing the prose and narration.

In the schema, Joyce identified the lungs as the organ for this chapter; indeed, the episode features lots of comings and goings (inhales and exhales), and the diction is suffused with references to air and wind. In terms of the correspondence to Homer, the episode is named for Aeolus, the keeper of the winds, who gives Odysseus a magical sack of winds; appropriately, this chapter is filled with the hot air of political speeches, rhetorical devices, and the inflated prose of newspapers and newspapermen.


Ch8 Lestrygonian

Bloom moves through Dublin at lunchtime; the giant Lestrygonians become gluttonous citizens.

Pineapple rock, lemon platt, butter scotch. A sugarsticky girl shovelling scoopfuls of creams for a christian brother. Some school treat. Bad for their tummies. Lozenge and comfit manufacturer to His Majesty the King. God. Save. Our. Sitting on his throne sucking red jujubes white.
A sombre Y. M. C. A. young man, watchful among the warm sweet fumes of Graham Lemon’s, placed a throwaway in a hand of Mr Bloom.
Heart to heart talks.
Bloo... Me? No.
Blood of the Lamb.
His slow feet walked him riverward, reading. Are you saved? All are washed in the blood of the lamb. God wants blood victim. Birth, hymen, martyr, war, foundation of a building, sacrifice, kidney burntoffering, druids’ altars. Elijah is coming. Dr John Alexander Dowie restorer of the church in Zion is coming.
Is coming! Is coming!! Is coming!!!
All heartily welcome.
Paying game. Torry and Alexander last year. Polygamy. His wife will put the stopper on that. Where was that ad some Birmingham firm the luminous crucifix. Our Saviour. Wake up in the dead of night and see him on the wall, hanging. Pepper’s ghost idea. Iron Nails Ran In.
..................
From Butler’s monument house corner he glanced along Bachelor’s walk. Dedalus’ daughter there still outside Dillon’s auctionrooms. Must be selling off some old furniture. Knew her eyes at once from the father. Lobbing about waiting for him. Home always breaks up when the mother goes. Fifteen children he had. Birth every year almost. That’s in their theology or the priest won’t give the poor woman the confession, the absolution. Increase and multiply. Did you ever hear such an idea? Eat you out of house and home. No families themselves to feed. Living on the fat of the land. Their butteries and larders.

Guide
With Stephen heading off at the end of “Aeolus” for a few pints, Mr. Bloom is once again the sole focalized character of the “Lestrygonians” episode. We join him at 1:00 pm - lunchtime - as he moves south on O’Connell Street from the newspaper office toward the River Liffey. Food is on the brain as he passes Graham Lemon’s Confectioner’s Hall, a candy shop. The episode is peppered with many references to food, and the schema lists “peristaltic prose” as the technique of this episode. In digestion, peristalsis refers to the intestinal muscles contracting and relaxing to push food along; Joyce’s style in “Lestrygonians” employs this concept as Bloom moves in starts and stops through the belly of downtown Dublin.
He accepts an evangelical flyer from a young YMCA fellow, skims its contents (“Are you saved? … Elijah is coming” (8.10-13)), before dismissing this sort of proselytizing advertisement as a for-profit enterprise. As he approaches the River Liffey, he glances to his right to see Dilly Dedalus waiting outside of Dillon’s auction house on Bachelor’s Walk. Stephen’s little sister appears malnourished and wears a tattered dress. Bloom presumes that she is selling off furniture and reflects on the collapse of the Dedalus household since the passing of Stephen’s mother; he notes the folly of enormous Catholic families.

Ch9 Scylla and Charybdis

Stephen debates in the library, intellectual dangers replacing physical monsters.

Urbane, to comfort them, the quaker librarian purred:
—And we have, have we not, those priceless pages of Wilhelm Meister. A great poet on a great brother poet. A hesitating soul taking arms against a sea of troubles, torn by conflicting doubts, as one sees in real life.
He came a step a sinkapace forward on neatsleather creaking and a step backward a sinkapace on the solemn floor.
A noiseless attendant setting open the door but slightly made him a noiseless beck.
—Directly, said he, creaking to go, albeit lingering. The beautiful ineffectual dreamer who comes to grief against hard facts. One always feels that Goethe’s judgments are so true. True in the larger analysis.
Twicreakingly analysis he corantoed off. Bald, most zealous by the door he gave his large ear all to the attendant’s words: heard them: and was gone.
Two left.
—Monsieur de la Palice, Stephen sneered, was alive fifteen minutes before his death.
—Have you found those six brave medicals, John Eglinton asked with elder’s gall, to write Paradise Lost at your dictation? The Sorrows of Satan he calls it.
Smile. Smile Cranly’s smile.
First he tickled her
Then he patted her
Then he passed the female catheter
For he was a medical
Jolly old medi...
—I feel you would need one more for Hamlet. Seven is dear to the mystic mind. The shining seven W.B. calls them.
Glittereyed his rufous skull close to his greencapped desklamp sought the face bearded amid darkgreener shadow, an ollav, holyeyed. He laughed low: a sizar’s laugh of Trinity: unanswered.
Orchestral Satan, weeping many a rood
Tears such as angels weep.
Ed egli avea del cul fatto trombetta.

Guide
The ninth episode of the novel, “Scylla & Charybdis,” takes place in the National Library, where Stephen Dedalus will deliver his much-anticipated (though sparsely attended) lecture on Shakespeare and Hamlet. Excepting the second half of “Aeolus,” we have largely been in Bloom’s mind since “Proteus,” so the return to the intellectual density, social tension, and discursive loftiness of Stephen’s thoughts in “Scylla & Charybdis” can be somewhat jarring…perhaps even off-putting. Some readers may be tempted to quit. Don’t!

Like with “Proteus,” my goal is to get you through this episode and on to the rest of the book; indeed, a comprehensive guide to this episode would necessitate literally thousands of explanations and revelations. Just about every line contains a Shakespearean allusion!

(My note: in the notes on this section at the back of the Oxford World's 
Classic edition one page required nearly two pages of notes)

Ch10 Wandering Rocks

A fragmented view of Dublin's citizens; interweaving paths, like "rocks" blocking progress.

The superior, the very reverend John Conmee S. J. reset his smooth watch in his interior pocket as he came down the presbytery steps. Five to three. Just nice time to walk to Artane. What was that boy’s name again? Dignam. Yes. Vere dignum et iustum est. Brother Swan was the person to see. Mr Cunningham’s letter. Yes. Oblige him, if possible. Good practical catholic: useful at mission time.

A onelegged sailor, swinging himself onward by lazy jerks of his crutches, growled some notes. He jerked short before the convent of the sisters of charity and held out a peaked cap for alms towards the very reverend John Conmee S. J. Father Conmee blessed him in the sun for his purse held, he knew, one silver crown.

Father Conmee crossed to Mountjoy square. He thought, but not for long, of soldiers and sailors, whose legs had been shot off by cannonballs, ending their days in some pauper ward, and of cardinal Wolsey’s words: If I had served my God as I have served my king He would not have abandoned me in my old days. He walked by the treeshade of sunnywinking leaves: and towards him came the wife of Mr David Sheehy M.P.

—Very well, indeed, father. And you, father?

Father Conmee was wonderfully well indeed. He would go to Buxton probably for the waters. And her boys, were they getting on well at Belvedere? Was that so? Father Conmee was very glad indeed to hear that. And Mr Sheehy himself? Still in London. The house was still sitting, to be sure it was. Beautiful weather it was, delightful indeed. Yes, it was very probable that Father Bernard Vaughan would come again to preach. O, yes: a very great success. A wonderful man really.


Guide
As the anxiety of navigating “Scylla and Charybdis” dissipates, Joyce offers “Wandering Rocks” as an interlude to mark the midway point in the novel (if not by pages, at least by episodes). Written as 18 mini-episodes (plus a concluding coda) that occur across the city of Dublin between 2:55 and 4:00 pm, “Wandering Rocks” is often referred to as Ulysses in miniature. Indeed, the episode’s interlocking parts and painstaking attention to time and place inspires much the same awe and appreciation the reader feels for the novel as a whole.

The schema lists “mechanics” as the art for this episode, and we can think of each of the 18 sections as a gear in the Dublin machine. Short scenes or occurrences in one section might reappear (or pre-appear) in other sections of the episode divorced from space (but not time) in a device called interpolation. Think of these interpolations as teeth from one gear momentarily interlocking with another gear in the turning Dublin machine.

Ch11 Sirens

In the bar/music hall, Bloom is tempted by the "siren song" of sensuality.

(My note: this makes a bit more sense when you read the Guide and discover that Bronze & Gold are two young women (different hair colour) staring out of a window watching a procession go by)

Bronze by gold heard the hoofirons, steelyringing.
Imperthnthn thnthnthn.
Chips, picking chips off rocky thumbnail, chips.
Horrid! And gold flushed more.
A husky fifenote blew.
Blew. Blue bloom is on the.
Goldpinnacled hair.
A jumping rose on satiny breast of satin, rose of Castile.
Trilling, trilling: Idolores.
Peep! Who’s in the... peepofgold?
Tink cried to bronze in pity.
And a call, pure, long and throbbing. Longindying call.
Decoy. Soft word. But look: the bright stars fade. Notes chirruping answer.
O rose! Castile. The morn is breaking.
Jingle jingle jaunted jingling.
Coin rang. Clock clacked.
Avowal. Sonnez. I could. Rebound of garter. Not leave thee. Smack. La cloche! Thigh smack. Avowal. Warm. Sweetheart, goodbye!
Jingle. Bloo.
Boomed crashing chords. When love absorbs. War! War! The tympanum.
A sail! A veil awave upon the waves.
Lost. Throstle fluted. All is lost now.
Horn. Hawhorn.
When first he saw. Alas!
Full tup. Full throb.
Warbling. Ah, lure! Alluring.
Martha! Come!
Clapclap. Clipclap. Clappyclap.
Goodgod henev erheard inall.
Deaf bald Pat brought pad knife took up.
A moonlit nightcall: far, far.
I feel so sad. P. S. So lonely blooming.
Listen!
The spiked and winding cold seahorn. Have you the? Each, and for other, plash and silent roar.
Pearls: when she. Liszt’s rhapsodies. Hissss.
You don’t?
Did not: no, no: believe: Lidlyd. With a cock with a carra.
Black. Deepsounding. Do, Ben, do.

Guide
Whereas most of the episodes in Ulysses begin in medias res (in the middle of things) and at a remove (temporally, spatially, or both) from the previous episode’s conclusion, characters in Episode 11 pick up almost exactly where they left off in Episode 10. You’ll recall that the coda of the “Wandering Rocks” episode depicts the procession of the Viceregal cavalcade through the heart of the city and shows various Dubliners as they watch and react to the grandeur of this event. The “Sirens” episode opens its action by repeating nearly verbatim the description of two barmaids, Miss Douce (bronze) and Miss Kennedy (gold), peering through the windows of the Ormond Hotel bar to catch a glimpse as the procession rolls along the north bank of the Liffey at 3:38 pm.

The correspondence of the sirens refers to two birdwomen whose beautiful singing tempts sailors off course, luring their ships to wreck on a craggy island. In The Odyssey, Odysseus plugs his crew’s ears with wax to prevent them from hearing the sirens’ song; Odysseus himself, clever enough to have his cake and eat it too, ties himself to his mast so that he can enjoy the sirens’ song while preventing himself from steering the ship toward the temptresses. Jackson I. Cope argues that Miss Douce and Miss Kennedy are the sirens, trying to tempt Boylan from his imminent adultery with Molly. Additionally, he suggests that Bloom’s “impulse to interfere in their affair is a siren-song that would destroy them all.”

With this episode’s depiction of singing performances along with its musical prose elements (such as onomatopoeia, linguistic refrains, and syncopated syntax), “Sirens” directly engages and seeks to replicate the qualities of music, which is the art listed on the Gilbert/Linati Schemas for this episode. The prominence of this musical style in the episode’s discourse signals a departure from what we have come to regard as the normal narration of the novel; in “Sirens,” the Arranger’s influence is dominant.

The first 62 lines of the episode are jarring and largely incomprehensible to the first-time reader. In The Argument of Ulysses, Stanley Sultan describes this opening section as an “overture,” introducing the major notes of the chapter’s language and plot. While Sultan’s label is apt, I also like to think of this section as an orchestra warming up prior to a performance; the reader is like an audience listening to musicians practicing trills and phrases of the composition to be performed. It is cacophony here, but it will all make sense when properly arranged and elaborated upon in the performance/chapter ahead.

Ch12 Cyclops

Bloom is attacked verbally by a nationalist ("The Citizen"), echoing the Cyclops's one-eyed view.

I was just passing the time of day with old Troy of the D. M. P. at the corner of Arbour hill there and be damned but a bloody sweep came along and he near drove his gear into my eye. I turned around to let him have the weight of my tongue when who should I see dodging along Stony Batter only Joe Hynes.
—Lo, Joe, says I. How are you blowing? Did you see that bloody chimneysweep near shove my eye out with his brush?
—Soot’s luck, says Joe. Who’s the old ballocks you were talking to?
—Old Troy, says I, was in the force. I’m on two minds not to give that fellow in charge for obstructing the thoroughfare with his brooms and ladders.
—What are you doing round those parts? says Joe.
—Devil a much, says I. There’s a bloody big foxy thief beyond by the garrison church at the corner of Chicken lane—old Troy was just giving me a wrinkle about him—lifted any God’s quantity of tea and sugar to pay three bob a week said he had a farm in the county Down off a hop-of-my-thumb by the name of Moses Herzog over there near Heytesbury street.
—Circumcised? says Joe.
—Ay, says I. A bit off the top. An old plumber named Geraghty. I’m hanging on to his taw now for the past fortnight and I can’t get a penny out of him.
—That the lay you’re on now? says Joe.
—Ay, says I. How are the mighty fallen! Collector of bad and doubtful debts. But that’s the most notorious bloody robber you’d meet in a day’s walk and the face on him all pockmarks would hold a shower of rain. Tell him, says he, I dare him, says he, and I doubledare him to send you round here again or if he does, says he, I’ll have him summonsed up before the court, so I will, for trading without a licence. And he after stuffing himself till he’s fit to burst. Jesus, I had to laugh at the little jewy getting his shirt out. He drink me my teas. He eat me my sugars. Because he no pay me my moneys?


Guide
The “Cyclops” episode of Ulysses tells the story of what occurred in Barney Kiernan’s pub between the hours of 5:00 and 6:00 pm from the narrative perspective of a working class Dubliner. I want to emphasize the past tense of “occurred” in the previous sentence because the nameless narrator (referred to as the Nameless One or “I”) is probably telling this story in a pub at some later point - since he lacks financial means, storytelling is the currency he exchanges for drinks. Perhaps the closest the novel approaches to moralizing, the “Cyclops” episode directly engages questions of nationalism and prejudice, love and hate, violence and injustice, but Joyce only provides the opportunity to engage these lofty topics while viewing Bloom through the eyes of someone prejudiced against him.

If not the climax of the novel, the “Cyclops” episode certainly represents a significant flashpoint in the events of Bloomsday. The anti-Semitism that has lingered in the background of many of Bloom’s social interactions throughout the day emerges as an overt and aggressive force, principally represented in the character of the Citizen, an Irish nationalist with an eyepatch and a myopic view of who qualifies as truly Irish.


Ch13 Nausicaa

Bloom encounters Gerty MacDowell on the beach, a parody of romantic ideals.

The summer evening had begun to fold the world in its mysterious embrace. Far away in the west the sun was setting and the last glow of all too fleeting day lingered lovingly on sea and strand, on the proud promontory of dear old Howth guarding as ever the waters of the bay, on the weedgrown rocks along Sandymount shore and, last but not least, on the quiet church whence there streamed forth at times upon the stillness the voice of prayer to her who is in her pure radiance a beacon ever to the stormtossed heart of man, Mary, star of the sea.

The three girl friends were seated on the rocks, enjoying the evening scene and the air which was fresh but not too chilly. Many a time and oft were they wont to come there to that favourite nook to have a cosy chat beside the sparkling waves and discuss matters feminine, Cissy Caffrey and Edy Boardman with the baby in the pushcar and Tommy and Jacky Caffrey, two little curlyheaded boys, dressed in sailor suits with caps to match and the name H. M. S. Belleisle printed on both. For Tommy and Jacky Caffrey were twins, scarce four years old and very noisy and spoiled twins sometimes but for all that darling little fellows with bright merry faces and endearing ways about them. They were dabbling in the sand with their spades and buckets, building castles as children do, or playing with their big coloured ball, happy as the day was long. And Edy Boardman was rocking the chubby baby to and fro in the pushcar while that young gentleman fairly chuckled with delight. He was but eleven months and nine days old and, though still a tiny toddler, was just beginning to lisp his first babyish words. Cissy Caffrey bent over to him to tease his fat little plucks and the dainty dimple in his chin.
—Now, baby, Cissy Caffrey said. Say out big, big. I want a drink of water.
And baby prattled after her:
—A jink a jink a jawbo.


Guide
The “Nausicaa” episode takes place at twilight, around 8:00 pm, on the Sandymount strand, where Mr. Bloom is having a rest from a rather busy and draining day. After escaping the Citizen by carriage at the end of the "Cyclops" episode, Bloom and Martin Cunningham visited Mrs. Dignam to review her late husband’s insurance policy. In The Odyssey, a shipwrecked, storm-tossed, and exhausted Odysseus washes ashore in Phaeacia, where Princess Nausicaa finds him naked and brackish. ........

As Ulysses ventures into ever stranger and more disparate literary territories, its styles and voices will continue to shift, shaping our experience of the plot. ...... there is some debate over the narrative voice and perspective here. You might consider that the episode begins in the style of a cheap romance novel and/or women’s magazine

The “Nausicaa” episode opens on the beach at around 8:00 pm with three young women (Edy Boardman, Cissy Caffrey, and Gerty MacDowell), two toddler boys (Tommy and Jacky Caffrey), and a baby in a stroller. Within this group, Gerty quickly becomes the narrative’s central figure; the text focuses on her physique, her feelings, and her desires. Her characterization is heavily adorned with references to beauty products, fashion, and efforts at physical self-improvement (almost like an amalgamation of ads from a beauty magazine). In a nearby church and simultaneous to the events on the strand, a service for the Virgin Mary takes place; in these ways, the “Nausicaa” episode presents many of the patriarchy’s ideals of femininity: a beautiful object, a pure virgin, and refuge “to the stormtossed heart of man”.

Ch14 Oxen of the Sun

In a maternity hospital; language styles evolve from ancient to modern, symbolizing birth and life cycles.

Deshil Holles Eamus. Deshil Holles Eamus. Deshil Holles Eamus.
Send us bright one, light one, Horhorn, quickening and wombfruit. Send us bright one, light one, Horhorn, quickening and wombfruit. Send us bright one, light one, Horhorn, quickening and wombfruit.
Hoopsa boyaboy hoopsa! Hoopsa boyaboy hoopsa! Hoopsa boyaboy hoopsa!
Universally that person’s acumen is esteemed very little perceptive concerning whatsoever matters are being held as most profitably by mortals with sapience endowed to be studied who is ignorant of that which the most in doctrine erudite and certainly by reason of that in them high mind’s ornament deserving of veneration constantly maintain when by general consent they affirm that other circumstances being equal by no exterior splendour is the prosperity of a nation more efficaciously asserted than by the measure of how far forward may have progressed the tribute of its solicitude for that proliferent continuance which of evils the original if it be absent when fortunately present constitutes the certain sign of omnipollent nature’s incorrupted benefaction. For who is there who anything of some significance has apprehended but is conscious that that exterior splendour may be the surface of a downwardtending lutulent reality or on the contrary anyone so is there unilluminated as not to perceive that as no nature’s boon can contend against the bounty of increase so it behoves every most just citizen to become the exhortator and admonisher of his semblables and to tremble lest what had in the past been by the nation excellently commenced might be in the future not with similar excellence accomplished if an inverecund habit shall have gradually traduced the honourable by ancestors transmitted customs to that thither of profundity that that one was audacious excessively who would have the hardihood to rise affirming that no more odious offence can for anyone be than to oblivious neglect to consign that evangel simultaneously command and promise which on all mortals with prophecy of abundance or with diminution’s menace that exalted of reiteratedly procreating function ever irrevocably enjoined?


Guide
The “Oxen of the Sun” episode takes place between 10:00 and 11:00 pm at the Holles Street Maternity Hospital, where Stephen is continuing his bender with three medical students (Dixon, Lynch, and Madden) and a few other miscellaneous Dubliners (Lenehan, Punch Costello, and Crotthers). Mr. Bloom will soon join this group, having taken a tram from Sandymount to Merrion Square in order to check on Mrs. Purefoy, who has been in labor at the hospital for three days.

In The Odyssey, Odysseus and his crew land on the island of Thrinacia, home of the sungod’s immortal sheep and longhorn cattle. Both Circe and Tiresias have warned Odysseus to avoid this island entirely; at the very least, they mustn’t harm Helios’s sacred oxen – sacred symbols of fertility – lest the gods punish the offenders with annihilation. ..................
Joyce uses a series of 32 parodies to represent the “embryonic development” he identified in the schema as his technique for the “Oxen of the Sun” episode. These parodies chart the growth of literary style from preliterate pagan incantations into Middle English, followed by the Latinate styles of Milton, imitations of satirists such as Swift, and eventually 19th century novelists such as Dickens. This episode, then, is the ultimate authorial powerflex: Joyce exerts his mastery of every form of writing that led to the birth of Ulysses. Demonstrating Joyce’s unparalleled literary dexterity and depth of knowledge, this episode is an impressive execution of an audacious idea; Joyce estimated that he spent 1,000 hours writing it. Yet none of that makes it particularly fun to read.

Because these parodies of various styles dominate the surface of the narrative, “Oxen” is perhaps the most challenging episode to get through. Some might even call it tedious. Joyce himself described it as “the most difficult episode […] both to interpret and to execute” (Letters I 137). Harriet Shaw Weaver, Joyce’s benefactor, wrote with some bite that “Oxen” “might also have been called ‘Hades,’ for the reading of it is like being taken the rounds of hell” (JJ 476). So yeah, it’s hard. But having come this far in your reading of Ulysses, you’ll go a little further, even if that means spending a few hours in hell. When you re-read the novel in a few years, you might skim or even skip it. For now, though, let’s do our best to get through it together, because there are certainly some clever moments to enjoy and many important details to gather. At the very least, we can appreciate the episode’s ingenuity.


Ch15 Circe

In a brothel (Nighttown), Bloom and Stephen experience hallucinations — chaos and transformation.

(The Mabbot street entrance of nighttown, before which stretches an uncobbled tramsiding set with skeleton tracks, red and green will-o’-the-wisps and danger signals. Rows of grimy houses with gaping doors. Rare lamps with faint rainbow fans. Round Rabaiotti’s halted ice gondola stunted men and women squabble. They grab wafers between which are wedged lumps of coral and copper snow. Sucking, they scatter slowly. Children. The swancomb of the gondola, highreared, forges on through the murk, white and blue under a lighthouse. Whistles call and answer.)

THE CALLS: Wait, my love, and I’ll be with you.
THE ANSWERS: Round behind the stable.
(A deafmute idiot with goggle eyes, his shapeless mouth dribbling, jerks past, shaken in Saint Vitus’ dance. A chain of children ’s hands imprisons him.)
THE CHILDREN: Kithogue! Salute!
THE IDIOT: (Lifts a palsied left arm and gurgles.) Grhahute!
THE CHILDREN: Where’s the great light?
THE IDIOT: (Gobbling.) Ghaghahest.
(They release him. He jerks on. A pigmy woman swings on a rope slung between two railings, counting. A form sprawled against a dustbin and muffled by its arm and hat snores, groans, grinding growling teeth, and snores again. On a step a gnome totting among a rubbishtip crouches to shoulder a sack of rags and bones. A crone standing by with a smoky oillamp rams her last bottle in the maw of his sack. He heaves his booty, tugs askew his peaked cap and hobbles off mutely. The crone makes back for her lair, swaying her lamp. A bandy child, asquat on the doorstep with a paper shuttlecock, crawls sidling after her in spurts, clutches her skirt, scrambles up. A drunken navvy grips with both hands the railings of an area, lurching heavily. At a corner two night watch in shouldercapes, their hands upon their staffholsters, loom tall. A plate crashes: a woman screams: a child wails. Oaths of a man roar, mutter, cease. Figures wander, lurk, peer from warrens. In a room lit by a candle stuck in a bottleneck a slut combs out the tatts from the hair of a scrofulous child. Cissy Caffrey’s voice, still young, sings shrill from a lane.)

CISSY CAFFREY:
I gave it to Molly
Because she was jolly,
The leg of the duck,
The leg of the duck.

(Private Carr and Private Compton, swaggersticks tight in their oxters, as they march unsteadily rightaboutface and burst together from their mouths a volleyed fart. Laughter of men from the lane. A hoarse virago retorts.)

THE VIRAGO: Signs on you, hairy arse. More power the Cavan girl.
CISSY CAFFREY: More luck to me. Cavan, Cootehill and Belturbet. (She sings.)
I gave it to Nelly
To stick in her belly,
The leg of the duck,
The leg of the duck.

(Private Carr and Private Compton turn and counterretort, their tunics bloodbright in a lampglow, black sockets of caps on their blond cropped polls. Stephen Dedalus and Lynch pass through the crowd close to the redcoats.)

PRIVATE COMPTON: (Jerks his finger.) Way for the parson.
PRIVATE CARR: (Turns and calls.) What ho, parson!
CISSY CAFFREY: (Her voice soaring higher.)
She has it, she got it,
Wherever she put it,
The leg of the duck.

(Stephen, flourishing the ashplant in his left hand, chants with joy the introit for paschal time. Lynch, his jockeycap low on his brow, attends him, a sneer of discontent wrinkling his face.)
STEPHEN: Vidi aquam egredientem de templo a latere dextro. Alleluia.
(The famished snaggletusks of an elderly bawd protrude from a doorway.)
THE BAWD: (Her voice whispering huskily.) Sst! Come here till I tell you. Maidenhead inside. Sst!
STEPHEN: (Altius aliquantulum.) Et omnes ad quos pervenit aqua ista.
THE BAWD: (Spits in their trail her jet of venom.) Trinity medicals. Fallopian tube. All prick and no pence.

Guide
Ok, this one’s a doozy. Beginning shortly before midnight, the “Circe” episode uses the form of a play to portray a kaleidoscopic blend of real and imaginary happenings over the course of an hour in Dublin’s brothel district. “Circe” takes up nearly 150 pages in the Gabler edition of Ulysses, making it about as long as the first eight episodes of the novel combined. 

 (My note: I only managed 70 pages before giving up, so I have to go back and read the rest - now done! Phew!)

Worried over Stephen’s drunken condition, Bloom has followed him into Nighttown in hopes of taking care of him. Between the end of “Oxen” and the start of “Circe,” a sundering occurred between Stephen and Buck Mulligan in Westland Row Station; perhaps Buck simply abandoned Stephen, or maybe there was a physical confrontation. Regardless, Buck and Haines have departed without Stephen on the last train toward the Tower in Sandycove. As Stephen anticipated all the way back in “Telemachus,” he will not sleep there tonight. Buck has usurped his place. Accompanied by Lynch (and trailed by Bloom), Stephen has taken the train from Westland Row to Amiens Station and is now on his way to a brothel. Bloom is hustling to catch up after stopping briefly to buy snacks.

In The Odyssey, Odysseus and his crew land on Aeaea, and a team of scouts discover the palace of Circe, a witch goddess. Circe invites Odysseus’s men inside for a drink and then magically turns them into pigs. One man escapes to tell Odysseus about their comrades’ fate and Circe’s trickery. Odysseus bravely hopes to rescue his men from Circe’s enchantment; on the way to her house, Odysseus receives help from Hermes, who offers him a plan and equips him with moly, a magical herb that will protect him from Circe’s witchcraft. The plan works: the moly counters Circe’s magic, she swoons for Odysseus and transforms his crew from pigs back into men. Odysseus and Circe then make love. For a year. Finally, some of Odysseus’s crew shake him from the madness of his long Circean interlude and compel him to resume the journey home to Ithaca.

In early spring 1920, Joyce emerged from the 1,000 hours he had spent writing “Oxen” and turned his attention to “Circe.” He expected that this episode, like the few he had recently composed, would take him two to three months to complete. Little did he know that “Circe” would require eight drafts and take over half a year to write (Letters), much less that it would have the power to bewitch his creative process and entirely transform Ulysses. This episode, with its exhaustive reprises of virtually every character, object, and idea introduced in the novel thus far, would compel Joyce to revise much of what he had previously written. Joyce estimated that he wrote a third of Ulysses at the proof stage of the revision process (Beach 58), arranging codependent details all over the novel and weaving a web of intratextual puzzles that will “keep the professors busy for centuries” (JJ 521).

Ch16 Eumaeus

Bloom and Stephen meet in a cabman’s shelter — uncertain recognition, father-son connection hinted.

Preparatory to anything else Mr Bloom brushed off the greater bulk of the shavings and handed Stephen the hat and ashplant and bucked him up generally in orthodox Samaritan fashion which he very badly needed. His (Stephen’s) mind was not exactly what you would call wandering but a bit unsteady and on his expressed desire for some beverage to drink Mr Bloom in view of the hour it was and there being no pump of Vartry water available for their ablutions let alone drinking purposes hit upon an expedient by suggesting, off the reel, the propriety of the cabman’s shelter, as it was called, hardly a stonesthrow away near Butt bridge where they might hit upon some drinkables in the shape of a milk and soda or a mineral. But how to get there was the rub. For the nonce he was rather nonplussed but inasmuch as the duty plainly devolved upon him to take some measures on the subject he pondered suitable ways and means during which Stephen repeatedly yawned. So far as he could see he was rather pale in the face so that it occurred to him as highly advisable to get a conveyance of some description which would answer in their then condition, both of them being e.d.ed, particularly Stephen, always assuming that there was such a thing to be found. Accordingly after a few such preliminaries as brushing, in spite of his having forgotten to take up his rather soapsuddy handkerchief after it had done yeoman service in the shaving line, they both walked together along Beaver street or, more properly, lane as far as the farrier’s and the distinctly fetid atmosphere of the livery stables at the corner of Montgomery street where they made tracks to the left from thence debouching into Amiens street round by the corner of Dan Bergin’s. But as he confidently anticipated there was not a sign of a Jehu plying for hire anywhere to be seen except a fourwheeler, probably engaged by some fellows inside on the spree, outside the North Star hotel and there was no symptom of its budging a quarter of an inch when Mr Bloom, who was anything but a professional whistler, endeavoured to hail it by emitting a kind of a whistle, holding his arms arched over his head, twice.

Guide
Picking up the action immediately after the end of “Circe,” the “Eumaeus” episode covers the time between roughly 12:45 and 1:40 am. Mr. Bloom welcomes Stephen out of his stupor and takes him to a nearby cabman’s shelter for a quiet moment and some sustenance.

In The Odyssey, Odysseus returns home to Ithaca, emerges from an Athena-induced haze, disguises himself as a beggar, goes to the hut of Eumaeus, his swineherd. Rather than reveal himself immediately, Odysseus tells Eumaeus false stories about his identity and origin. After Eumaeus passes a loyalty test, Odysseus reveals his true identity. Later in Eumaeus’s hut, Odysseus is united with his son, Telemachus. Together, the three men plot an attack on the suitors plaguing Odysseus’s home and besetting his wife Penelope.

The style of the “Eumaeus” episode, identified by Joyce in his schemas as “narrative (old),” has been met with divergent critical opinions. Richard Ellmann claims that the episode “struggles clumsily for the right expression” (Ellmann 151), while Stanley Sultan describes it as “the attempt of a poorly-educated man to impress by discoursing with sophisticated eloquence” (Sultan 364). David Hayman calls the episode “a tired, threadbare, flatulent narrative larded with commonplaces” whereby “the arranger conveys with surprising accuracy the drink and fatigue-dulled sentiments of both protagonists” (Hayman 102-03). Maybe.

In my opinion, the most useful understanding of the style of this episode relies on the Uncle Charles Principle. In short, “the Uncle Charles Principle entails writing about someone much as that someone would choose to be written about” (Kenner 21). Applying this concept to the current episode, “Eumaeus” is written in the style that Bloom would have employed if he himself had written the episode; indeed, Bloom later announces his intention to compose exactly this piece of literature: “suppose he were to pen something out of the common groove (as he fully intended doing) at the rate of one guinea per column. My experiences, let us say, in a Cabman’s Shelter” (16.1229-31). So, rather than condemning “Eumaeus” as stilted, over-ornamented prose with garbled syntax and imprecise diction, we might instead consider the episode’s use of Bloom’s own literary style (flawed as it may be) as the ultimate celebration of Bloom himself (flawed as he may be). By ceding such control to Mr. Bloom, Joyce offers “the book’s most profound tribute to its hero” (Kenner 38). With this gesture in mind, the episode’s flabby sentences and cringe-worthy cliches become endearing a la Bloom himself. The episode’s inferior style, though, is also a demonstration of Joyce’s extreme facility with language. Just as it takes a very good piano player to play a song really poorly (you have to know the exact wrong notes to play to make it sound truly awful), it takes an immensely talented writer to intentionally write this badly. Bearing this in mind, the reader can appreciate the humour embedded in the style of this particular episode.


Ch17 Ithaca

Bloom takes Stephen home; order is restored but questions remain.

What parallel courses did Bloom and Stephen follow returning?

Starting united both at normal walking pace from Beresford place they followed in the order named Lower and Middle Gardiner streets and Mountjoy square, west: then, at reduced pace, each bearing left, Gardiner’s place by an inadvertence as far as the farther corner of Temple street: then, at reduced pace with interruptions of halt, bearing right, Temple street, north, as far as Hardwicke place. Approaching, disparate, at relaxed walking pace they crossed both the circus before George’s church diametrically, the chord in any circle being less than the arc which it subtends.

Of what did the duumvirate deliberate during their itinerary?

Music, literature, Ireland, Dublin, Paris, friendship, woman, prostitution, diet, the influence of gaslight or the light of arc and glowlamps on the growth of adjoining paraheliotropic trees, exposed corporation emergency dustbuckets, the Roman catholic church, ecclesiastical celibacy, the Irish nation, jesuit education, careers, the study of medicine, the past day, the maleficent influence of the presabbath, Stephen’s collapse.

Did Bloom discover common factors of similarity between their respective like and unlike reactions to experience?

Both were sensitive to artistic impressions, musical in preference to plastic or pictorial. Both preferred a continental to an insular manner of life, a cisatlantic to a transatlantic place of residence. Both indurated by early domestic training and an inherited tenacity of heterodox resistance professed their disbelief in many orthodox religious, national, social and ethical doctrines. Both admitted the alternately stimulating and obtunding influence of heterosexual magnetism.

Were their views on some points divergent?

Stephen dissented openly from Bloom’s views on the importance of dietary and civic selfhelp while Bloom dissented tacitly from Stephen’s views on the eternal affirmation of the spirit of man in literature. Bloom assented covertly to Stephen’s rectification of the anachronism involved in assigning the date of the conversion of the Irish nation to christianity from druidism by Patrick son of Calpornus, son of Potitus, son of Odyssus, sent by pope Celestine I in the year 432 in the reign of Leary to the year 260 or thereabouts in the reign of Cormac MacArt († 266 A.D.), suffocated by imperfect deglutition of aliment at Sletty and interred at Rossnaree. The collapse which Bloom ascribed to gastric inanition and certain chemical compounds of varying degrees of adulteration and alcoholic strength, accelerated by mental exertion and the velocity of rapid circular motion in a relaxing atmosphere, Stephen attributed to the reapparition of a matutinal cloud (perceived by both from two different points of observation Sandycove and Dublin) at first no bigger than a woman’s hand.

Was there one point on which their views were equal and negative?

The influence of gaslight or electric light on the growth of adjoining paraheliotropic trees.

Guide
The “Ithaca” episode continues the action of the novel more or less seamlessly from the end of “Eumaeus” (which itself is continuous from the end of “Circe”). The time at the start of the present episode is perhaps 1:40 am. Mr. Bloom and Stephen Dedalus are walking north from the cabman’s shelter to the Bloom’s home in Eccles Street, a .8 mile walk that should take them roughly 20 minutes.

In The Odyssey, Odysseus has finally returned to his home on the rocky island of Ithaca. After revealing himself to his son in Eumaeus’s hut, the heroes plan Odysseus’s recapturing of his palace and assault on the suitors; he will remain disguised as a beggar until he strings his mighty bow and shoots an arrow through a dozen axes, proving his strength and precision.

The notion of precision might be useful as we orient ourselves to the style of the “Ithaca” episode. In the Gilbert schema, Joyce listed the technique for this episode as “catechism (impersonal),” a multivalent reference. Most obviously, the term catechism applies to the Catholic texts that use a series of questions and answers to define the theological and moral beliefs of the church. Joyce would have been intimately familiar with this form of writing from his Jesuit education. Just as influential, though, a catechetical or Socratic method of question and answer would have been central to the classroom instruction Joyce experienced in his late 19th century schooling; ..............and this meticulous form replicates Odysseus’s precision with the bow and arrow.

But the episode also playfully pushes this precision to an absurd extreme, an over-the-top exactitude Hugh Kenner credits to Bloom’s favorite weekly magazine, Tit-Bits: “each issue […] contained a page called ‘Tit-Bits Inquiry Column’: answers to questions no one would have thought to ask” (Kenner 145). ....................

Like all of Ulysses, then, “Ithaca” elevates Bloom into the sphere of timeless epic heroes while also exposing him to be profoundly unexceptional. .................

It may be no surprise, then, that “Ithaca,” which Joyce called the “ugly duckling of the book,” was his “favourite episode” in the novel 


Ch18 Penelope

Molly Bloom’s monologue mirrors Penelope's loyalty and humanity — a stream of consciousness "yes."

Yes because he never did a thing like that before as ask to get his breakfast in bed with a couple of eggs since the City Arms hotel when he used to be pretending to be laid up with a sick voice doing his highness to make himself interesting for that old faggot Mrs Riordan that he thought he had a great leg of and she never left us a farthing all for masses for herself and her soul greatest miser ever was actually afraid to lay out 4d for her methylated spirit telling me all her ailments she had too much old chat in her about politics and earthquakes and the end of the world let us have a bit of fun first God help the world if all the women were her sort down on bathingsuits and lownecks of course nobody wanted her to wear them I suppose she was pious because no man would look at her twice I hope Ill never be like her a wonder she didnt want us to cover our faces but she was a welleducated woman certainly and her gabby talk about Mr Riordan here and Mr Riordan there I suppose he was glad to get shut of her and her dog smelling my fur and always edging to get up under my petticoats especially then still I like that in him polite to old women like that and waiters and beggars too hes not proud out of nothing but not always if ever he got anything really serious the matter with him its much better for them to go into a hospital where everything is clean but I suppose Id have to dring it into him for a month yes and then wed have a hospital nurse next thing on the carpet have him staying there till they throw him out or a nun maybe like the smutty photo he has shes as much a nun as Im not yes because theyre so weak and puling when theyre sick they want a woman to get well if his nose bleeds youd think it was O tragic and that dyinglooking one off the south circular when he sprained his foot at the choir party at the sugarloaf Mountain the day I wore that dress Miss Stack bringing him flowers the worst old ones she could find at the bottom of the basket anything at all to get into a mans bedroom with her old maids voice trying to imagine he was dying on account of her to never see thy face again though he looked more like a man with his beard a bit grown in the bed father was the same ......

Guide
Since the beginning of our odyssey through Bloomsday, we have been journeying toward Molly’s perspective, delivered here in “Penelope” unfiltered and with minimal interruption. The promise of hearing from Molly in the final episode has been a motivating interest, pulling us through the novel; she seems certain to provide the last piece of the puzzle. Joyce referred to Molly’s monologue in “Penelope” as “the indispensable countersign to Bloom’s passport to eternity” (Letters I 160). Sure enough, we can spend eternity reading this novel and this episode in particular, experiencing the text differently each time. In typical Joycean fashion, “Penelope” will confound our desires for closure and satisfaction, but it guarantees a life’s worth of interesting moments to scrutinize.

Some readers of “Penelope” will find Molly offensive. D. H. Lawrence described the episode as “the dirtiest, most indecent, obscene thing ever written” (qtd. in Chabon). Its obscenity contributed to Ulysses being banned in the English-speaking world for over a decade after its initial publication in 1922. A friend of Joyce’s named Mary Colum denounced “Penelope,” calling it “an exhibition of the mind of a female gorilla” (qtd. in Herring 57). While that description seems a bit harsh on Molly, the audacity of a man attempting to represent Woman (much less any individual woman) was roundly rejected in early feminist reactions to the text. Many felt that Joyce had misunderstood and misrepresented the female mind and perspective. Indeed, Molly Bloom herself visited Joyce in dreams, castigating him for “meddling” in her business (Lawrence 72).

Or, maybe Joyce was a protofeminist, creating Molly as a sexually liberated woman with freely expressed desires and the agency to speak and do as she wishes. In later criticism, scholars began to recognize a shared purpose between feminism and Joyce’s efforts in Ulysses generally and “Penelope” specifically to expose and disrupt the patriarchal conventions of literature and representation (Lawrence 74), and some even considered Molly’s soliloquy the paragon of écriture féminine, a style whereby language “is fluidly organized and freely associative. Thus, it has the capacity to both reflect and create human experience beyond the control of patriarchy” (Tyson 93). In this view, “Penelope” opens the door to new post-patriarchal literary forms.

Outside of feminism, scholars have shifted their reading of Molly in each generation. In the 1920s, she was obscene. In the 30s, scholars sought to canonize Joyce and Ulysses, so they therefore avoided criticizing her vulgarity “for fear that in impugning Molly’s reputation, they would tarnish Joyce’s” (McCormick 29); instead, they described her as an idealized force of Nature, a Gaia earth-mother-goddess, suppressing her sexuality. Once Joyce had been safely canonized, it became possible for critics in the 50s and 60s to attack Molly’s sensuality and label her a “whore,” reflecting a larger post-WWII antifeminist reaction (McCormick 29). Then, in the 70s and 80s, post-structuralists couch her “language, desire, and even her very subjectivity” as products of “her historical formation” (McCormick 33). To be sure, you can spend years delving deeply into the scholarly lenses and debates that have sought to define Molly Bloom. I myself got a bit lost in this rabbit hole while preparing to write this episode guide, and I could have happily spent much longer weighing brilliant people’s opinions about this fascinating character.

However, the project at hand, as always on this site, is to support you as you complete your reading of Ulysses. I will reference various scholars’ ideas where relevant in this guide, but I intend to keep focused primarily on the text itself.

So, let’s review what we, as readers of Ulysses, know about this woman. A 33 year old soprano of local fame, Molly Bloom has been married for 15 years to Leopold Bloom, with whom she has had two children: a daughter, Milly, who just turned 15 yesterday, and a son, Rudy, who died in infancy a decade ago. Molly Tweedy was born and raised in Gibraltar because her father, Major Brian Tweedy, was stationed there as a soldier in the Royal Dublin Fusiliers unit of the British military. On this day, June 16th, 1904, she has had extramarital sex with Blazes Boylan, the man who is managing her upcoming concert tour of Belfast and Liverpool. Also on this day, she received breakfast in bed from her husband and tossed a coin to a beggar.

In The Odyssey, Penelope has waited faithfully for 20 years for her husband’s return from the Trojan War, spending the last four years or so rebuffing over 100 suitors seeking her hand in remarriage. Under this pressure, she devises an ingenious plan to delay selecting a new husband: she claims, citing tradition and decency, that she must weave a funeral shroud for her father-in-law prior to remarrying. She works at her loom all day, and then each night secretly unweaves her work from the previous day. Just as Penelope, in her cleverness, is a perfect match for Odysseus, we might say the same of Molly and Leopold Bloom in their shared characteristics of wantonness, sensitivity, and charity.

The “Penelope” episode consists of eight “sentences” separated by paragraph breaks. There is no punctuation in the final version of the text, although “much of the punctuation was deleted only in the proofs, after most of her well-formed sentences had been constructed” (M. Ellmann 102). In many ways, Molly’s flowing stream of consciousness is unique in all of literature. Joyce wrote that “Penelope has no beginning, middle or end” (Letters I 172), and he listed in the schema ∞ as the hour for this episode. This symbol has a variety of possible meanings: it represents infinity and is an 8 lying down on its side, indicating the 8 sentences that comprise the episode while also depicting the image of Molly lying down in bed.

James Joyce Project - full text of Ulysses with colour coded links (new site in Beta-testing)

Tuesday, 15 April 2025

Behind The Scenes at the Museum by Kate Atkinson

This book announced the arrival of Kate Atkinson as a new novelist, and won the Whitbread Book of The Year in 1995, beating The Moor's Last Sigh by Salman Rushdie and a biography of William Ewart Gladstone by Roy Jenkins. She has now become an established and well-read writer with 13 further books, including Life after Life, and a God in Ruins both of which have been filmed.

"I exist!". It is 1951 and Ruby Lennox has come into existence as a fertilized egg after her mother Bunty has received the amorous attentions of her half-drunk husband George. Amazingly and unscientifically this egg narrates the first chapter of the novel as though from some clestial viewpoint. I found this hard to take; the reader can allow a degree of poetic licence but this was scientific licence gone mad - a fertilized egg does not have “tiny naked heels" to tap together! I nearly stopped reading, however I was enjoying the downbeat tone and sardonic humour of the writing and the clever description of  family life of the 1950s - the years of my own childhood.

Following chapter one comes footnote (i) which leaps back in time to 1888.and a significant moment in the life of Alice Barker, Ruby's’s great-grandmother. We get a brief account of her back story – her mother Sophia, marriage to a drunkard farmer, a multitude of children and pregnant again. She is unhappy and despairing of her life when one particular day ......

This pattern of chapter then reference, present then past, continues throughout the book. Ruby's life unfolds together with the stories of people on her family tree, who are often represented by things like a locket, a button, a photo or a clock. The reader is presented with artifacts from people's lives as though seeing objects in a museum and then taken behind the scenes to learn their history. It's a clever way to represent the way we are all connected to our ancestors.

After just 38 pages I realised I was losing track of who was who and who was when so searched on the Internet for a list of characters. Including dolls and dogs there are173 separate names with 60 who make it onto Ruby's family tree (see below - contains spoilers). A reviewer of  another of Kate Atkinson's novels says:

“It’s a book that teems with people and places, events and incidents, and is written with the garrulous enthusiasm for which its author has rightly become celebrated.”

The story of Ruby from her birth in York, through her childhood and teen years to her forties when she decides to live out the rest of her life on the Shetland Isles is told via a series of remembered incidents, the coronation of the Queen, a holiday, a death, a wedding and so on, which is how memory works for us all.  

This is an interesting novel but rather gloomy despite the humour. No one seemed to be living a happy and fulfilled life - people were leaving home in a huff or were pregnant again, or were looking to spice up the boreom of their lives by having an affair. Some disappeared but  turned up later in Canada and Austrailia.

Chapter 2 is called "Birth and Ruby makes her appearance in the world. The chapter ends with the words, "My name is Ruby. I am a precious jewel, I am a drop of blood, I am Ruby Lennox". As she grows and changes Ruby searches for who she is. Something is missing from her life and once found she is able to settle on who she is mesnt to be.

At its heart, the book is a meditation on how our lives are shaped by seemingly random events and the stored “exhibits” of personal and collective history. The museum in the title serves as a metaphor of all our lives, where memories, secrets, and relics of the past are preserved and re-examined.

Ruby's Family Tree (Spoiler alert!)


Monday, 17 March 2025

Poems referenced by The Painted Veil.

 Lift Not The Painted Veil by Percy Bysshe Shelley

Lift not the painted veil which those who live
Call Life: though unreal shapes be pictured there,
And it but mimic all we would believe
With colours idly spread,—behind, lurk Fear
And Hope, twin Destinies; who ever weave
Their shadows, o'er the chasm, sightless and drear.
I knew one who had lifted it—he sought,
For his lost heart was tender, things to love,
But found them not, alas! nor was there aught
The world contains, the which he could approve.
Through the unheeding many he did move,
A splendour among shadows, a bright blot
Upon this gloomy scene, a Spirit that strove
For truth, and like the Preacher found it not.

An Elegy On The Death Of A Mad Dog by Oliver Goldsmith

Good people all, of every sort,
Give ear unto my song;
And if you find it wondrous short,
It cannot hold you long.

In Islington there was a man
Of whom the world might say,
That still a godly race he ran—
Whene'er he went to pray.

A kind and gentle heart he had,
To comfort friends and foes;
The naked every day he clad—
When he put on his clothes.

And in that town a dog was found,
As many dogs there be,
Both mongrel, puppy, whelp, and hound,
And curs of low degree.

This dog and man at first were friends;
But when a pique began,
The dog, to gain some private ends,
Went mad, and bit the man.

Around from all the neighbouring streets
The wond'ring neighbours ran,
And swore the dog had lost its wits
To bite so good a man.

The wound it seemed both sore and sad
To every Christian eye;
And while they swore the dog was mad,
They swore the man would die.

But soon a wonder came to light
That showed the rogues they lied,—
The man recovered of the bite,
The dog it was that died!


The Painted Veil by Somerset Maugham

The only important thing in a book, is the meaning it has for you.
Somerset Maugham

This review contains spoilers

This was my second reading of The Painted Veil, and just like my second read of The Blue Flower I got much more out of it the second time round. The title is taken from a short poem by Shelly, that begins, “Lift not the painted veil, which those who live call life”. Maugham constructs the novel round the core ideas in this poem.

Synopsis

The Painted Veil is the story of Kitty Fane, a young, self-absorbed socialite who marries Walter Fane, a dedicated bacteriologist, more to escape her over-bearing mother than for love. Finding herself in Hong Kong, bored with her life and unfulfilled in her marriage, Kitty embarks on an affair with a charming colonial officer Charles Townsend. When Walter discovers the betrayal, he gives her a stark ultimatum: either leave him for Townsend or accompany him to a remote, cholera-ridden town in China. Kitty quickly discovers Townsend’s supposed love for her is a sham, she has no real choice, and reluctantly goes with Walter. The harsh realities of the cholera-stricken town, the heroic lives of some nuns and the sacrificial dedication of her husband, force her to confront the shallowness of her life. Stripped of former comforts and illusions she begins a journey towards self-awareness. Among the nuns ahe sees a love that is far deeper than fevered emotion and becomes aware of her own emptiness and need for redemption. She begins a search for a different life, a life of meaning and purpose.

Characters:

Kitty is the central character and almost everything is seen through her eyes. We know her thoughts, opinions and judgements and in the first section of the book Maugham hammers home her frivolity, her prejudices and her selfish nature. Her life is empty of meaning, in sharp contrast to that of her husband, Walter.

Walter is something of an enigma. Our judgement of him is coloured by Kitty’s assessment. To her he is too shy, too introspective and lacking in charm; she is bored by him and does not love him. We know he is intelligent and very much in love with Kitty and that he tries to make her happy, but following her affair he seems cold, cruel and vengeful. When Kitty first visits the convent, we see a different Walter. Kitty learns how thoughtful and tender he is, how he sooths crying babies. The nuns revere him and the Mother Superior calls him a saint. Kitty admits to herself he has remarkable qualities, even a strange though unattractive greatness.

Charles Townsend in contrast was “a common fellow and second-rate”. He had treated Kitty like a mere plaything; his words of devotion had meant nothing and yet despite all this he was still lodged firmly in her heart. Towards the end of the novel, Kitty discovers to her shame the new life she feels is before her is easily swept aside by a desire she thought was dead.

Waddington plays an important part in Kitty’s path to redemption. He is a shrewd observer of human nature - knowledgeable, cynical and unconventional. He is a bridge between the Chinese and Colonial worlds. Through her conversations with him, Kitty begins to see people and the world differently. She asks him about Taoism and after Waddington has explained she says, “Does it mean anything?” Waddington replies, “Sometimes, when I've had half a dozen whiskies and look at the stars, I think perhaps it does.”

The Mother Superior also has a profound effect on Kitty. While Waddington represents a more detached, Eastern-style acceptance of life, the Mother Superior impresses Kitty by following a selfless, Christian ideal of duty, service, and sacrifice. Kitty cares for the children alongside the nuns in the convent but despite their kindness she “felt shut out, …. from some mysterious garden of the spirit, after which with all her soul she hankered. She felt on a sudden alone, as she had never felt alone before.”

The Painted Veil Lifted

The painted veil of the poem represents the shallow outward appearance of life, “unreal shapes” and “colours idly spread” that just “mimic all we would believe”. The veil needs to be lifted to see the reality that lies behind.

Throughout the novel, Maugham lifts the veil from Kitty’s eyes.

He shows how her upbringing moulded her character to be self-centred, shallow, and set the illusions of her life in place. Her affair with Townsend and his betrayal shows him to be as self-centred and shallow as she is. This shock begins the lifting of the veil.

In Mei-tan-fu, Kitty is exposed to new realities: being surrounded by death brings a realisation of her own mortality; Waddington with his insights and common sense, counters her prejudices and superficiality; the nuns have given up everything that Kitty held dear yet their lives have meaning and purpose; as she cares for the orphans she finds within herself new depths of love, and she comes to realise the only way to heal her relationship with Walter is through forgiveness.

Walter’s Death

Kitty believes that Walter is trapped in resentment and bitterness by her infidelity. It is a burden weighing him down and the only release is for him to forgive her, not for her sake but for his.

As he lies dying, Kitty says to him, “‘Walter. I beseech you to forgive me. I'm so desperately sorry for the wrong I did you. I so bitterly regret it’. He said nothing. He did not seem to hear. She was obliged to insist. It seemed to her strangely that his soul was a fluttering moth, and its wings were heavy with hatred……she saw two tears run slowly down his wasted cheeks. ‘Oh, my precious my dear, if you ever loved me. I know you love me, and I was hateful. I beg you to forgive me. I've no chance now to show my repentance. Have mercy on me. I beseech you to forgive me’. …. She saw that he tried to speak. She leaned over him so she might hear, but he spoke quite clearly.

‘The dog it was that died’”

This is the last line is from a poem by Oliver Goldsmith in which a supposedly saintly man is bitten by a mad dog. The man was outwardly virtuous but had a hidden poisonous nature. The man was more poisonous than the dog.

Walter is confessing he was wrong to think himself more righteous or morally superior to Kitty. His early desire for her death through cholera, his continuing coldness and obsession with punishing her were more poisonous than her adultery.

How to Live

Waddington's wisdom:

Kitty says to Waddington, 
“I'm looking for something and I don't quite know what it is, but I know that it's very important for me to know it and if I did it would make all the difference. Perhaps the nuns know it. When I'm with them, I feel they hold a secret which they will not share with me. I don't know why came into my head that if I saw this Manchu woman, I should have an inkling of what I'm looking for. Perhaps she would tell me if she could.
What makes you think she knows it?
Kitty gave him a sidelong glance but did not answer. Instead, she asked him a question.
Do you know it?
He smiled and shrugged his shoulders.
Tao. Some of us look for the way in opium, some in God. Some others in whiskey and some in love. It is all the same way. And it leads nowhither.”

The Mother Superior has different wisdom to impart

“One cannot find peace in work or in pleasure, in the world or in a convent, but only in one's soul.”

"Remember, that it is nothing to do your duty, that is demanded of you, and no more meritorious than to wash your hands when they are dirty. The only thing that counts is the love of duty. When love and duty are one, then grace is in you, and you will enjoy a happiness which passes all understanding."

A Beautiful Life.

Kitty is not convinced by the Mother Superior, she says to Waddington, “If the nuns have sacrificed their lives for the life to come and there is no life to come, they've been cheated.” Waddington replies, “I wonder. I wonder if it matters that what they aimed at is an illusion. Their lives are in themselves beautiful. The beautiful life that is the perfect work of art.”

No Clue
On the journey back to Hong Kong. Kitty observes the passing landscape and thinks back to her time in the city. She imagines the houses, the streets and convent as if they are the backdrop to a play with all the people of the city playing their varied parts. But what did it all mean? It was important to know and yet she had no clue, no clue.

Peace
By the end of the novel Kitty has found her answer. She remembers a day on the journey out to the city.

“One morning they set out in their chairs while it was still dark, and as the day broke, she divined rather than saw a scene of such breathtaking loveliness that for a brief period the anguish of her heart was assuaged. It reduced to insignificance all human tribulation. The sun rose, dispelling the mist, and she saw, winding onward as far as the eye could reach, among the rice fields, across a little river and through undulating country, the path they were to follow. Perhaps her faults and follies, the unhappiness she had suffered were not entirely vain. If she could follow the path that now she dimly discerned before her. Not the path that kind, funny old Waddington had spoken of that lead nowhither, but the path those dear nuns at the convent followed so humbly, the path that led to peace.

Conclusion

The Painted Veil explores themes of disillusionment, the fragility of human relationships, and the transformative power of suffering. Kitty’s journey from superficiality to introspection, set against the backdrop of class, colonialism, disease and danger, is a meditation on the age-old question - what gives a human life meaning and purpose? 


Links

Painted Veil poem and Goldsmith's Elegy

Somerset Maugham - British Heritage

Somerset Maugham - Wikipedia

Thursday, 6 March 2025

Wlliam Allingham Diaries

William Allingham (1824–1889) was an Irish poet, diarist, and editor, best known for his lyrical poetry and his connections with the literary figures of the Victorian era. 

Allingham’s education was informal, though he was an avid reader from a young age. After his father’s death, he took up a job as a customs officer in Lymington to support himself, a position he held for much of his early career. However, his true passion was poetry, and he began writing and publishing verses in periodicals.

His literary career brought him into contact with some of the most prominent writers and artists of the time, including Alfred, Lord Tennyson, Thomas Carlyle, and the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood, particularly Dante Gabriel Rossetti. Rossetti illustrated Allingham's Day and Night Songs, and the two maintained a strong friendship. Allingham was also influenced by William Wordsworth and Robert Browning.

Marriage
In 1874, he married the artist Helen Paterson, later known as Helen Allingham, who became a well-regarded watercolorist, famous for her romanticised paintings of Victorian rural life.

Diaries
These were published posthumously in 1907 edited by his wife, and provide a rich and insightful account of Victorian literary and artistic life.

The Great & The Good & The Changing World
Allingham was well-connected in the literary world, and his diaries record meetings with prominent writers such as Alfred, Lord Tennyson, Thomas Carlyle, Robert Browning, and members of the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood, including Dante Gabriel Rossetti. His observations offer intimate portrayals of these figures, providing details about their personalities, habits, and creative processes.

Allingham comments on social and political events of the Victorian era. There are passing references to Darwin and his theory of evolution (referred to as Darwinism), belief in God, and spiritualism which was then all the vogue. His comments capture the attitudes and concerns of the period, including debates on art, science. religion, and nationalism.

Death
On Sunday the 17th Nov 1889 it was evident that the end was very ear. When asked if he had any requests to make, he said ' No, my mind is at rest ' : then to his wife

'And so, to where I wait, come gently on." 
' I thank you (to Mr. Buckston Browne) — I thank every one.'

After this he lay in a kind of trance, and died peace-fully about two o'clock in the afternoon of the next day, November the 18th.

Once that morning he said, ' I am seeing things that you know nothing of.'

The cremation, which was by his special wish, took place at Woking. A few friends and relations only were present. There was no service : Mr. F. G. Stephens, the oldest of the friends there gathered together, read aloud
 
Allingham's own Poet's Epitaph : —

Body to purifying flame,
Soul to the Great Deep whence it came.
Leaving a song on earth below,
An urn of ashes white as snow.

The urn was buried in the churchyard at Bally-shannon.

No funeral gloom, my dears, when I am gone,
Corpse-gazings, tears, black raiment, grave-yard grimness ;
Think of me as withdrawn into the dimness,
Yours still, you mine, remember all the best
Of our past moments, and forget the rest ;
And so, to where I wait, come gently on.

(from: "My Native Land" by Lydia Maria Child.)

Quotes from The Diaries

God
Thursday 14th May `1877: Thomas Carlisle - I know nothing whatever of God except what I find within myself - the feeling of the eternal difference between right and wrong.

William Allingham talking to Tennyson. In 1884.

As we turned down Packhorse Lane, Tennyson spoke of Eternal punishment as an obsolete belief.
I said, At Whitley Station, hangs on the wall, a large book of Bible texts, one page for each day of the month. Today I read. All the dead shall arise, the righteous to eternal life, the wicked to everlasting damnation.
Tennyson. It's not a right translation.
Allingham. But it's the authoritative teaching of the Church.
Tennyson. Have you read Farrah's book?
Allingham. I never read such books.
Tennyson. Oh, but here he proves from original sources that no such doctrine existed in the early days of Christianity.
I told Tennyson that Bishop Wilberforce was very proud of having saved the Athanasian Creed when the Archbishop of Canterbury was for giving it up. Which interested him.
Did he? My father. (I think it was his father) would never read the Athanasian creed.
As we entered the back wicket and went along the shady little walk to the house, Tennyson said. You're not orthodox. And I can't call myself orthodox. Two things, however, I've always firmly convinced of – God - and that death will not end my existence.
Allingham. So I believe.
Tennyson. Stopping and turning round. Do you hold these?
Allingham. I do.

Lincolnshire - Tennyson's reminiscences

Preachers : ' Coom in your rags, coom in your filth, Jesus'll take ye, Jesus won't refuse ye.' 'Time has two ends, and the Law cooms down wi' a bang ! ' 'Glory’ a very favourite word.

Lincolnshire manners. ' One of my brothers met a man in the lane near our house and said in a friendly voice, "Good-night ! " to which the man replied, "Good night — and dom you ! " I asked a man one day, " Do you know what o'clock it is? " he answered, " Noa ! and I don't want to." '

Tennyson tells of old Lincolnshire farmer near his father's. He said to him one day civilly, Mr _____, so why don't you mend your fences? The old fellow stooped down and tied his shoelace carefully, then straightened himself and said, I've never mended a fence, and I never will.

Tennyson had a story of a Lincolnshire farmer who said, when he came out of church — ' burned for ever and for ever! I can't believe that : no constitution could stand it

Charles Darwin & Russell Wallace - Evolution & Spiritualism

Tennyson now took Barnes and me to his top room. Darwinism — 'Man from ape — would that really make any difference '.

Friday May 2. — Bright and mild. To Carlyle 3.15. We walk, Kensington Gardens. Carlyle. said, 'Here is May, poor May! not forward with her work this time — Tyndall has not come near me lately; I must touch him up. O yes, he's very fond of me — but perhaps he was vexed by an outburst of mine against Darwinism. I find no one who has the deep abhorrence of it that I have in my heart of hearts ! Science, falsely so called. Tyndall is Irish, but not an accurate Irishman. He is jocular, and not without a touch of blarney. Has Huxley (defender of Darwin) indigestion .? — lucky not to have had experience of it sooner. Huxley attacks Herbert Spencer, with many polite bows and recognitions.'

Carlyle. spoke of Darwinism. ' I don't care three ha'pence for the Darwinian Theory.' By and by he said, ' It is impossible to believe otherwise than that this world is the work of an Intelligent Mind, The Power which has formed us — He (or It — if that appears to any one more suitable) has known how to put into the human soul an ineradicable love of justice and truth. The best bit for me in Kant is that saying of his, " Two things strike me dumb with astonishment — the Starry Heavens and the Sense of Right and Wrong in the Human Soul." 

[Actual quote: "Two things fill the mind with ever new and increasing admiration and awe, the more often and the more steadily reflection is occupied with them: the starry heaven above me and the moral law within me," in his Critique of Practical Reason.]

William. Allingham. — 'It might be taken as a foreshadowing of Darwinism — the origin of man in an amphibious lepidosyren.'

August 11. — To Freshwater ; engage bedroom over little shop, and to the Darwins. Dr. Hooker in lower room writing away at his Address ; going to put ' Peter Bell's ' primrose into it and wants the exact words. Upstairs Mrs. Darwin, Miss D. and Mr. Charles Darwin himself, — tall, yellow, sickly, very quiet. He has his meals at his own times, sees people or not as he chooses, has invalid's privileges in full, a great help to a studious man.

Charles Darwin expected, but comes not. Has been himself called ' The Missing Link.' Luncheon. Then T. and I walk into croquet -ground, talking of Christianity.

February 22. — Drove with Carlyle. — Darwin and Haeckel. C. : ' For Darwin personally I have great respect ; but all that of " Origin of Species," etc., is of little interest to me. What we desire to know is, who is the Maker? and what is to come to us when we have shuffled off this mortal coil. Whoever looks into himself must be aware that at the centre of things is a mysterious Demiurgus — who is God, and who cannot in the least be adequately spoken of in any human words.'

Friday, November 6. — Fine, walked from Sandhills to Aldworth, through Haslemere, muddy roads, yellow russet woods. The Bucktons there, T. and Mr. B. on Natural History. T. asks ' How can Evolution account for the ant : 'Mr. B. says the theory presents many difficulties. He is studying the English cicadae. We go to hall door to see the B.'s off, then Tennyson and I take a short walk. He asks me to stay the night, and I accept.

I told him about Alfred Wallace, (Worked in the tropics & came up with the theory of evolution independently of Darwin) whom we visited last Saturday, and Spiritualism. Wallace a thorough-going believer — but has had no experiences himself. Also, he never visualises his thoughts. I suggested that to such a man the mere visualising power of some other minds might appear supernatural, he having nothing like it in his experience.

At luncheon, talk about the tropic woods : Wallace said you would find one kind of tree in flower for about a week, and at another time another kind of tree in flower for a short time, but you might come again and again and find no flowers at all ; there were never in the Tropics such masses of floral colour as in an English Spring.

To the Study. Wallace gave details of table-rapping, table-prancing, and so forth, his own experiences and other people's. He never doubts any statement whatever in favour of ' Spiritualism,' and has an answer to every objection. ' Maskelyne and Cooke do wonderful things.' — * Yes, partly by the help of mediumship.'

Discussion on Spiritualism and table rapping

Wallace said it was absurd to suppose that Matter could move itself. I ventured to remark that Matter, so far as we can penetrate, does move itself, indeed is perpetually in motion. He rejoined that in table rapping, etc. The phenomena were manifestly governed by an intelligences like our own. The means of communication between the unseen world and ours were few and difficult.

Here, Tennyson said, “A great ocean, pressing round us on every side and only leaking in by a few chinks, which Wallace took no notice. But went on to describe instances of Spirit writing on slates by Slade and others.

I fear my tone all through was hardly respectful to the spirits.

Somehow or other a sudden digression was made to politics, and W. came out with a strong opinion of the worthlessness of the House of Lords and the absurdity of the hereditary principle.

Tennyson referred with praise to Wallace book Tropical Nature and remarked, You have said something very bold about matter. I think matter more mysterious than spirit. I can conceive in a way what spirit is, but not matter.

Wallace. — ' I conceive Matter not as a substance at all, but as points of energy^ and that if these were withdrawn Matter would disappear.'

Wallace— ' So far from a material atom being indestructible, I believe that all the Matter in existence might be immediately destroyed by the withdrawal of the sustaining Force.'


Tennyson said. Is a very strange thing that according to Wallace, none of the spirits that communicate with men ever mentioned God or Christ.

I said I always felt that The Diety was infinitely above us. Another step will bring us no nearer.

Tennyson. Wallace says the system he believes in is a far finer than Christianity. It is Eternal Progress. I've always felt that there must be somewhere, someone who knows, that is God. But I am in hopes that I shall find something human in Him too.

Then we talked a little about Darwin, B. (Browning) saying that, whatever his merits as investigator, his philosophy was of little or no importance.

I told him of our neighbour Alfred Wallace, and how he had arrived, as it were, at the opposite goal from Darwin in what are called ' Supernatural questions ' ; Darwin at last believing almost nothing, Wallace almost anything

The Sacredness of Human Life?

Allingham and his wife Helen. Visit. Lord and Lady Wolesley.

Sunday 5th of June. 1887. I must not forget that at tea Lord Wolesley said, in his usual easy, cheerful way, that it was a great modern absurdity to value human life too highly. People have made idols of first one thing and then another, and now their idol was human life.

I said. Surely the notion of the Mystic sacredness of human life is very old, there’s Cain and Abel.

Lord Wolesley allowed this instance, but with a twinkle of the eye, went on. But look at the Lord God, how he slew thousands upon thousands, smote them hip and thigh. 

Helen put in. That was a long time ago. And we all smiled.

I said: A man I knew, Dr Bodichon of Algiers, had a serious theory for improving the world in the shortest possible time by the painless extinction of all useless human beings. He would have juries, including a large proportion of men of science, to decide on the fitness of this person or that to live.

Lord Wolseley. I entirely agree with your Algerian friend. I would have supplies of chloroform for gaols and hospitals for cripples, and so forth, and the world would be, débarrassé  (got rid of) of much trouble and expense.

I argued that this would lead to many abuses and that the general level of morality would be lowered. But Lord W maintained that we have nowadays an absurd and superstitious respect for human life and seemed to mean it. To lighten off the discussion, I repeated to Lady W. That Madam Bodichon had said to me in the midst of one of her husband’s discourses on scientific homicide. “He wouldn't himself drown a kitten.”

While Helen went in with the ladies for her parasol before starting. Lord W and I stood at the old porch looking at a hive of bees among the Ivy. Then he pointed at Lady W’s Pug. There's an absurd creature, it has a tail and it's alive, that's all you can say. I'm fond of dogs, but such a thing as that is good for no purpose.

Pugs would come under the chloroform act, I suggested.

Every one of them, he said.

Saturday, 15 February 2025

John Donne Sermon

They shall awake as Jacob did, and say as Jacob said, 
Surely the Lord is in this place, 
and this is no other but the house of God, and the gate of heaven, 
and into that gate they shall enter, 
and in that house they shall dwell, 
where there shall be no cloud nor sun, no darkness nor dazzling, 
but one equal light, 
no noise nor silence,
but one equal music, 
no fears nor hopes, 
but one equal possession, 
no foes nor friends, 
but an equal communion and identity, 
no ends nor beginnings, 
but one equal eternity.

Saturday, 1 February 2025

The People Immortal by Vasily Grossman

 

Vasily Grossman was a Soviet war reporter in WWII, He was born in in 1905, in Berdychiv , Ukraine - also the birthpalce of Joseph Conrad. He studied to be a chemical engineer but decided he really wanted to be a reporter. 

In June 1941 Hitler invaded the Soviet Union despite his non-agression pact with Stalin. Stalin's agents had warned him invasion was immanent but he ignored them and the German attack took them completely by suprise, To make matters worse Stalin had purged the army of it's top officers, his army was under-strength and under-led. The  Germans on the other hand were better led, better trained and much better equipped. The Russians were forced to retreat. They staged holding operations and counter attacks that only served to slow the advancing Germans. This is the setting for The People Immortal, in which a batallion thrown into the fight finds itself trapped and needing to breakout of the encirclement.

Grossman was a front line war reporter and witnessed this hopeless attempt to halt the invasion. His reports were very popular both with the troops and the civilian population. He was given leave of absence for two weeks in 1942 to write a novel to inspire the people in their struggle for survival and to give them hope of eventual victory. The result was The People Immortal.

At the beginning of the novel a researcher, Sergey Alexandrovich Bogariov, leaves his books and manuscripts to join the army as a high ranking political officer. 

Now and then he would remember the cool vaults of the institute's manuscript repository, a desk heaped with papers, a shaded lamp, the creak of the stepladder a librarian was moving from one bookshelf to another. Sometimes odd sentences from his unfinished study would come to mind and he would return to the questions that had so passionately engaged him throughout his life.

A young man, Ignatiev, leaves his village, his mother weeping and his father giving him the medal he won in WWI.

His  father had taken out two George Crosses he'd been awarded in the first German war and held them up to his son, his old hands trembling. "Look, Sima, "he had said, "here are my two silver Georges. There were two gold ones as well, but I put those into a Freedom Bond. Your old sapper father once blew up a bridge along with the best part of a German regiment." It was all too clear, however, that for all his attempts to be strong, the old man would rather have joined in with the women and wept. Semion was the favourite of his five sons, the jolliest and the most affectionate.

In thousands of trucks the army streams south and west to repel the invader.

There is dust everywhere: dark brick dust, yellow dust, fine grey dust. Men's faces look like the faces of corpses. These clouds of dust hanging over every road near the front line have been raised by hundreds of thousands of Red Army boots, by truck wheels and tank tracks, by road tractors and artillery, by the small hooves of pigs and sheep, by collective-farm horses and huge herds of cows, by collective-farm tractors, by the creaking carts of refugees, by the bast sandals of collective-farm foremen and the little shoes of girls leaving Bobruisk, Mozyr, Zhlobin, Shepetovka and Berdichev. Dust hangs over Ukraine and Belorussia; it swirls over the Soviet earth.

The People Immortal above all brings out the determination of the Soviet people to defend their homeland against the invading forces. The characters' unwavering commitment to their country and their willingness to make the ultimate sacrifice highlight the profound sense of duty and loyalty that pervades the novel.

Despite the brutality of war, the novel also emphasizes the importance of humanity and compassion. The characters' acts of kindness, their support for one another, and their enduring friendships serve as a testament to the enduring strength of the human spirit.

Grossman does not shy away from depicting the horrors and devastation of war. The graphic and unflinching portrayal of the battles, the suffering of the soldiers, and the destruction of towns and villages underscore the immense toll that the conflict takes on both the individuals and the nation.

The Russian people suffered terribly in the Second World War. They lost 27 million people, 16% of the population - the Uk lost 1%. No wonder they call it The Great Patriotic War. We read in our book group The Siege by Helen Dunmore, set in the siege of Leningrad that lasted 600 days before it was relieved. The people of Leningrad were reduced to starvation level, many of them dying of cold and hunger.

I've read. Grossman's Life and Fate and I've also read The Unwomanly Face of War by Svetlana Alexievich, which is a telling testimony to how the lives of ordinary people are tragically affected by war. Terrific courage, humanity and self-sacrifice on one hand and grim, deep hatred on the other.

The humanity of the people and their courage are what come across to me more than anything else in The People Immortal. The soldiers are trying to repel an enemy from taking their land, their home and their memories. The land where parents, grandparents and all their ancestors have toiled to build a heritage. They would rather sacrifice themselves ("hold their manhood cheap") than concede it to the invader?

There's a lovely passage near the end of the book when a messenger breaks through the encirclement to deliver letters:

""How the hell? The road's been cut." "I found ways, Comrade Commissar. I crept four kilometres on my belly. I crossed the river at night, and I shot a German sentry. Look— here's his shoulder strap." "Weren't you scared?" asked Bogariov. "Scared?" the soldier replied, with a little smile. "Why? My soul's not so precious. I'd price it at five kopeks. No more than a balalaika. Why should I be afraid for "Really?"

Grossman can certainly stir the heart. Here's a Land of Hope and Glory moment:

Great is the people whose sons die such stern, simple and sacred deaths on these vast fields of battle. The sky and the stars know about them; the earth has heard their last sighs; the unreaped rye and the roadside trees have witnessed their deeds. They sleep in the earth, with the sky, the sun and the clouds above them. They sleep soundly, they sleep an eternal sleep, as do their fathers and grandfathers, men who worked all their lives as carpenters, navvies, miners, weavers and peasant-farmers of a great land.

It reminded me of this little verse by Alexander Gray

This is my country,
The land that begat me.
These windy spaces
Are surely my own.
And those who here toil
In the sweat of their faces
Are flesh of my flesh,
And bone of my bone.

And also the Band of Brothers speech from Henry V

We few, we happy few, we band of brothers;
For he to-day that sheds his blood with me
Shall be my brother; be he ne'er so vile,
This day shall gentle his condition:
And gentlemen in England now a-bed
Shall think themselves accursed they were not here,
And hold their manhoods cheap whiles any speaks
That fought with us upon Saint Crispin's day.

But set this high patriotism against these lines from Wilfred Owen

If you could hear, at every jolt, the blood
Come gargling from the froth-corrupted lungs,
Obscene as cancer, bitter as the cud
Of vile, incurable sores on innocent tongues,--
My friend, you would not tell with such high zest
To children ardent for some desperate glory,
The old Lie: Dulce et decorum est
Pro patria mori.

(It is sweet and fitting to die for one's country)

"War is hell," (General Sherman). Yet we can't seem to rid ourselves of it.